Ingredients1 cup butter flavored shortening1 cup "Americano" Peanut Butter1 cup white sugar2 teaspoons baking soda1/2 cup teaspoon salt1 cup packed dark brown sugar2 teaspoons vanilla extract2 eggs2 c…

Okay, I know, another thumbprint cookie recipe... But trust me, you need to try this one. Not only are thumbprint cookies timeless, they're also delicious as well. While you could use any jelly o…